"To preserve the reputation of the Fraternity unsullied must be your constant care."


Saturday, March 03, 2018

Anti-Masonry: Be Careful What You Print

Here's a publishing tip: Don't go rooting around in Nazi propaganda for your stock photos.

During the anti-Masonic media tumult in England in February, the Manchester, England-based Catholic Times newspaper decided to weigh in with their own take on Freemasonry by publishing a letter from one of their readers on the 'Letters To The Editor' page. Blaring the headline, 'Dangers Lurking In Masonic System Of Philosophy,' the letter contained the usual array of canards against the fraternity. Given the Roman Catholic Church's official strictures against joining Masonic lodges, that's to be expected in a paper specifically skewed to that particular audience. If any organization has the right to create their own lopsided messaging that is specifically anti-Masonic in nature, it would certainly be the Catholic press, no matter how incorrect they might be.

Unfortunately, the large graphic they chose to accompany the letter couldn't have been a stupider choice. 

Immediately below the anti-Masonic letter was a different letter, this one a complaint that the paper had recently published blatantly anti-semitic material in an earlier issue. Anthony Silkoff, the Interfaith and Social Action officer of the Board of Deputies of British Jews  wrote a strong objection to the Catholic Times about a different reader’s letter which had alleged “a dramatic increase in Jewish voices on the radio”, as well as complaining about a “Jewish comedian” using sexual slang. Mr. Silkoff described the original letter in the paper as “racist drivel,” and his message was printed on the same page as the anti-Masonic letter. Right under it, as a matter of fact.

So what did the Catholic Times use to illustrate their reader's takedown of the fraternity? 

A photo that's appeared in books like The Hiram Key and others, and apparently has been around since the 1940s. 

The man, blindfolded with his trouser leg rolled up, was standing in front of a door with two Stars of David above it.
However, as Mr Silkoff highlighted, the picture of the man was taken from a Nazi-era antisemitic pamphlet about Jews using Freemasonry for subversion.
In a second letter to the Catholic Times, Mr Silkoff wrote: “At best, this is an incredibly grave mistake for you to use this Nazi image, and especially to use it on the same page where you had to print an apology for antisemitism.
“Where did you find this Nazi image and how did it end up in your paper?”
Mr Silkoff told the JC: “This episode has caused such concern because the Board really values the strong relationship we have with Catholics in Britain.
“We cooperate on lots of issues, particularly education and faith schools.
Our many friends in the Catholic church will be just as surprised as us to see this happen twice.”
Mr Flaherty said: “I had no idea the photograph was an antisemitic image.”
He said he had found the image on Google and not checked its source.
Ooops. Pesky details like that tend to reinforce the beliefs of Freemasons, especially in England and other European countries, that the press is never to be trusted.

Just as a matter of reference, two recent surveys of U.S. and Canadian Freemasons have shown that as many as 23% of Masons in those two countries identify themselves as Catholic. The fraternity does not restrict Catholics from joining. On the contrary—Freemasons do not ask a petitioner or their own members what particular faith they espouse. 

These two surveys were anonymous and unofficial. Freemasonry is designed specifically NOT divide its members by religion, politics, race, economic class, or profession. As a result, when Speculative Freemasonry first became widely known in the first half of the 18th century, the lodge was the first organization of its kind in England where Catholics, Protestants, and Jews met and socialized side by side without discrimination.

Apparently that is still considered a radical notion by a shrinking handful of people who just can't contain their contempt for it to this day.


  1. That photo has been around since the 1940's??? It's from The Hiram Key written by a Freemason and was used to speculate about a lot of Knights Templar Gar'bage'. What a crooked 'writer' you are Hodapp. Much like the oft repeated-by-em@son complete-masonic-crap-with-no-references you put in Freemasons-For-Dummies about 200,000 never existed european masons 'lost' in the holocaust. Desperate and crazy masonic claims.

    1. As I clearly stated in the post, it appeared in The Hiram Key. I did not contact Robert Lomas to ask his source for it. However, I did not allege its origin as Nazi propaganda - Mr. Silkoff did. I suggest you vent your spleen on him.

      As to the Holocaust figure, I happen to intimately know exactly what the original source was for that number that has since been repeated ad nauseam. I was that source, based upon difficult collection and tabulation of available data in 2004 from multiple sources, and again in 2008. As I said in the book, it's impossible to say how many Masons were murdered by the Nazis but estimates range anywhere from 80,000 to 200,000. The estimate was and is mine alone. Unfortunately, the For Dummies series doesn't permit footnoting in any way, and so citing sources in their books is always a pitched battle with editors, more so when the sources are multiple and complex.

      If I hear from Bob Lomas that his photo was original to him, I will of course correct this posting to reflect that.

    2. I should add also that the 80,000-200,000 figure obviously includes Jews and other "undesirables" that the Nazis imprisoned and executed who also happened to be Masons. I did not state that their SOLE crime to the Reich was their Masonic membership, as the SS needed little excuse or due process to hurl anyone into the camps or summarily execute. Masonic membership rates before the war and and just after its end in Germany and the other eleven countries invaded by Nazi forces are tedious to assemble, and even more difficult to correlate with actual imprisonment and death rates. That's why the spread is so large in the estimate.


Comments will not appear immediately, so be patient. I am forced to laboriously screen every post because I am constantly bombarded with spam. Anonymous postings on Masonic topics have the same status as cowans and eavesdroppers as far as I am concerned. If you post with an unknown or anonymous account, do not expect to see your comment appear.