West Virginia GM Boots OES Chapters Out of All Masonic Buildings

by Christopher Hodapp

NOTE: THIS STORY HAS BEEN UPDATED AS OF TUESDAY APRIL 8, 2025 AT 7:50AM:

I've had it confirmed that on March 21st, 2025, David Ray Pyle, Grand Master of the Grand Lodge AF&AM of West Virginia, issued a directive ordering all chapters of the Order of the Eastern Star to vacate all West Virginia Masonic buildings, effective immediately.

WV Grand Master David Ray Pyle

In his directive, he states that the O.E.S. in West Virginia no longer requires Masonic membership as a prerequisite. Consequently, they may no longer be permitted the use of any Masonic hall in that jurisdiction. He further states that the order extends to all Masonic building premisses, not just the lodge room itself.

GM Pyle has given the O.E.S. until July 21st to remove their property and ephemera from all Masonic halls, with a final drop-dead eviction date of September 21st.

GM Pyle's explanation in his directive is not exactly correct. The Masonic membership prerequisite still remains in place for men wishing to join the OES. Only the female relationship to an existing Mason has been dropped from their requirements.

Here's the change announced last November by the OES General Chapter:

WASHINGTON — At the Order of the Eastern Star (OES) 51st General Grand Chapter held in Florida [sic]* in October 2024, a resolution was passed to allow membership to all women who are sponsored by two members of the Order and are eligible for membership. This is a change from the previous requirement that OES members have a Masonic family affiliation or have been a members of a Masonic youth group. OES members nationwide are excited about this change as it will allow more women the opportunity to experience the friendship of Star and to make a difference in the world through its charitable works and kindness to others. 

Information regarding the OES can be found at the websites https://washingtonoes.org or https://easternstar.org

*To be completely factual, their triennial assembly last year was in Myrtle Beach, SC, not Florida. Thanks to Brother C. Winston Douglas for finding this OES announcement. 

To reiterate, the OES has ONLY dropped the familial relationship with an existing Freemason for women. Men joining the OES still are required to become a Master Mason first.

So, GM Pyle does have leeway, even with their regulations in West Virginia. And to cut off the OES, which is seen as being of benefit to hundreds of lodges throughout the U.S. (along with being an occasional goad to non-Mason men whose girlfriends, wives or daughters are OES members to seek Masonic membership), seems unduly harsh and shortsighted. While the OES has waned in popularity over the decades, there are still plenty of Masonic lodges that will struggle, or even close, if their Star chapter isn't there to support them (or share in the cost of running their building). It's pretty tough to see how kicking them to the curb when nothing substantive has changed benefits - or even protects - Freemasonry in West Virginia.

Says the Dummy Mason from the relative safety of his perch in Indiana where we don't load up our regulations with needlessly restrictive stuff like this. 

I don't recall exactly when West Virginia holds its annual communication, but I believe it's in November, which will be after Pyle's final eviction date. So even if someone can sponsor a resolution to change the rule and get it passed, it will be too late to stop the U-Haul trucks.

I've not yet seen an official reaction from the O.E.S. Grand Chapter of West Virginia or the O.E.S. General Grand Chapter in Washington, D.C. 

Wisconsin MasoniCon in Eau Claire This Saturday April 12th

by Christopher Hodapp

The MasoniCon season is heating up. Join me this Saturday, April 12th at the Wisconsin MasoniCon in Eau Claire, where I'll be speaking along with Steven Harrison of the Midnight Freemasons blog and author of Freemasons–Tales from the Craft.

The day will kick off at 10AM with a special meeting of the Silas Shepherd Lodge of Research #1843. Steven and I will speak after lunch.

This event takes place at the magnificent Eau Claire Masonic Temple located at 616 Graham Avenue, from 10AM to 6PM.

You can't beat the price - admission is free and lunch is provided. After the event, BBQ dinner from Famous Daves is a paltry $20.

For reservations and more information CLICK HERE. Technically, reservations are closed because of the lunch and dinner catering requirements, but the admission is free and organizers won't turn you away (as long as you feed yourself...)

April 13th: Scottish Rite Masonic Museum & Library Celebrates Its 50th

by Christopher Hodapp

The Scottish Rite Masonic Museum & Library in Lexington, Massachusetts is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year. If you've never visited, make the effort. It's one of the top Masonic museums in the U.S.

The Museum & Library first opened as the 'Museum of Our National Heritage' in 1975 to correspond with the American Bicentennial, on the 200th anniversary of the battles at Lexington and Concord. It was envisioned by then-Sovereign Grand  Commander George A. Newbury as an institution that could unite people after the divisive social upheavals of the 1960s, to help "build a better and more noble United States of America." 

Located next to the Scottish Rite NMJ's headquarters in Lexington, the museum started out with a small collection of souvenirs, historic Masonic objects, along with Civil War drawings, American portraits, decorative arts, and quilts loaned to them by other institutions. It also included the Van Gorden-Williams Library & Archives with more than 5,000 volumes and archives related to Scottish Rite Freemasonry. 

Since its beginning, the museum and library have worked to fulfill Newbury's vision of telling "the story of America" through programs, publications, exhibitions, and collections. Stories related to historic Lexington, Massachusetts, where the "shot heard 'round the world' was fired, kicking off the American Revolution, are frequently featured at the museum, to this day. But while the early museum concentrated on the patriotic telling of the American story, in recent decades the concentration has been more on presenting the history, artifacts and ephemera of Freemasonry and American fraternalism in general. No longer forced to rely on borrowed items from other museums, their own collection has become one of the best Masonic-related museums in the country.

On Sunday, April 13th there will be a rededication of the Museum, along with the opening of new exhibits and the kickoff of a year of special programming:

• "Looking Back, Moving Forward." For 50 years the museum and library has sought to fulfill Newbury’s vision “to tell a thrilling story—the story of America” through programs, publications, exhibitions, and collections. This exhibition explores how the museum and library’s collection has grown, changed, and helped tell this story over half a century.
• “Remembering the Battle of Bunker Hill.” This display memorializes the battle with a scale model of a 1794 Bunker memorial to Joseph Warren, souvenirs from the battle’s 1875 centenary, sheet music, and items related to the Bunker Hill Monument Masonic cornerstone laying ceremony in 1825.
• “Protest & Promise: The American Revolution in Lexington” will explore the events of April 19, 1775 with images, objects, and an in-depth look at this pivotal event and how it has been remembered.

The museum is located at 33 Marrett Road in Lexington, Massachusetts. Click here for more information about the museum, its April 13 events, and the exhibits.

Thanks To Rochester, New York's College of Freemasonry

by Christopher Hodapp

Last Saturday I was supposed to be in New York to make a presentation at the 2025 College of Freemasonry, sponsored by the Scottish Rite Valley of Rochester. The theme of the event was the 200th anniversary of the disappearance of William Morgan in nearby Batavia back in 1825. Alice and I were hoping to drag out the Airstream and camp out in upstate New York after this event. Unfortunately, Alice is still recuperating from her foot surgery performed back in February and is unable to walk yet, which means she can't be left alone for more than a few hours. So, I was unable to attend in person.

Fortunately, Shawn Eyer WAS there in person, and presented on the wider topic of Anti-Masonry in America. Thankfully, the Rochester brethren were quite understanding and permitted me to present my talk through the miracle of Zoom. Both John Bizzack and I gave our presentations via long distance and participated in a follow-up discussion. 

John's drew heavily on his 2022 book, The Age of Unreason, in which he carefully examines what is provably true in the Morgan case, versus the reams of exaggerations, untruths and downright fabrications made over the last two centuries on all sides of the story. If you know nothing about Morgan, start with John's volume. As a longtime veteran police investigator, he approaches the case with a dispassionate point of view, separating the serious evidence from the nonsense.

My presentation was about an almost completely unknown work from 1896 that most researchers into Morgan know nothing about: a bizarre, esoteric science fiction/adventure novel called Etidorpha, or the End Of the Earth. Written by a renowned Cincinnati pharmacist named John Uri Lloyd, it describes an un-named protagonist – known only as 'I Am The Man Who Did It' (or simply, 'I Am The Man') – who is clearly supposed to be Morgan himself. It describes his desire to seek the knowledge to Life, the Universe and Everything, which leads him to join the Masons; his falling on hard financial times; his moment of weakness in which he publishes an exposure of the fraternity's rituals; his arrest and kidnapping near the Canadian border... All obviously Morgan's story.

But Morgan's Masonic captors do NOT kill him. Instead, he is taken to a hidden cave in Kentucky where he encounters a strange, glowing blue humanoid figure who guides him down into the bowels of the Earth where he sees prehistoric creatures, experiences weightlessness, hallucinates in a forest of giant magic mushrooms, crosses a vast underground sea that defies all known physics, and finally meets Etidorpha (the goddess Aphrodite, spelled backwards) who informs him that he is to become part of a select group of enlightened adepts (presumably Masons) who have gently guided mankind throughout the Ages. 

Talk about rehabilitating both Morgan's AND his Masonic captors' reputations in one novel!

The book is a wild, esoteric variation on Verne's Journey to the Centre of the Earth, with a touch of Bulwer-Lytton's Vril, the Power of the Coming Race. Its illustrations were done by J. Augustus Knapp, who eventually became a Theosophist and illustrated Manly P. Hall’s famous esoteric work, The Secret Teachings of All Ages, 30 years later.

Finally, I wish to extend my deepest thanks to the College for presenting me with the Thomas W. Jackson Masonic Education Award. This particular award is especially poignant. I first spoke at the College back in 2010 and shared the podium with none other than Tom Jackson himself. I'd met and chatted with Tom at Masonic Week several times over the years, but it was the first opportunity we'd ever really had to spend some time together and get to know each other. He is sorely missed every day, so this beautiful award will be a constant reminder of his friendship.