Thanks To Rochester, New York's College of Freemasonry

by Christopher Hodapp

Last Saturday I was supposed to be in New York to make a presentation at the 2025 College of Freemasonry, sponsored by the Scottish Rite Valley of Rochester. The theme of the event was the 200th anniversary of the disappearance of William Morgan in nearby Batavia back in 1825. Alice and I were hoping to drag out the Airstream and camp out in upstate New York after this event. Unfortunately, Alice is still recuperating from her foot surgery performed back in February and is unable to walk yet, which means she can't be left alone for more than a few hours. So, I was unable to attend in person.

Fortunately, Shawn Eyer WAS there in person, and presented on the wider topic of Anti-Masonry in America. Thankfully, the Rochester brethren were quite understanding and permitted me to present my talk through the miracle of Zoom. Both John Bizzack and I gave our presentations via long distance and participated in a follow-up discussion. 

John's drew heavily on his 2022 book, The Age of Unreason, in which he carefully examines what is provably true in the Morgan case, versus the reams of exaggerations, untruths and downright fabrications made over the last two centuries on all sides of the story. If you know nothing about Morgan, start with John's volume. As a longtime veteran police investigator, he approaches the case with a dispassionate point of view, separating the serious evidence from the nonsense.

My presentation was about an almost completely unknown work from 1896 that most researchers into Morgan know nothing about: a bizarre, esoteric science fiction/adventure novel called Etidorpha, or the End Of the Earth. Written by a renowned Cincinnati pharmacist named John Uri Lloyd, it describes an un-named protagonist – known only as 'I Am The Man Who Did It' (or simply, 'I Am The Man') – who is clearly supposed to be Morgan himself. It describes his desire to seek the knowledge to Life, the Universe and Everything, which leads him to join the Masons; his falling on hard financial times; his moment of weakness in which he publishes an exposure of the fraternity's rituals; his arrest and kidnapping near the Canadian border... All obviously Morgan's story.

But Morgan's Masonic captors do NOT kill him. Instead, he is taken to a hidden cave in Kentucky where he encounters a strange, glowing blue humanoid figure who guides him down into the bowels of the Earth where he sees prehistoric creatures, experiences weightlessness, hallucinates in a forest of giant magic mushrooms, crosses a vast underground sea that defies all known physics, and finally meets Etidorpha (the goddess Aphrodite, spelled backwards) who informs him that he is to become part of a select group of enlightened adepts (presumably Masons) who have gently guided mankind throughout the Ages. 

Talk about rehabilitating both Morgan's AND his Masonic captors' reputations in one novel!

The book is a wild, esoteric variation on Verne's Journey to the Centre of the Earth, with a touch of Bulwer-Lytton's Vril, the Power of the Coming Race. Its illustrations were done by J. Augustus Knapp, who eventually became a Theosophist and illustrated Manly P. Hall’s famous esoteric work, The Secret Teachings of All Ages, 30 years later.

Finally, I wish to extend my deepest thanks to the College for presenting me with the Thomas W. Jackson Masonic Education Award. This particular award is especially poignant. I first spoke at the College back in 2010 and shared the podium with none other than Tom Jackson himself. I'd met and chatted with Tom at Masonic Week several times over the years, but it was the first opportunity we'd ever really had to spend some time together and get to know each other. He is sorely missed every day, so this beautiful award will be a constant reminder of his friendship.