According to a friend familiar with the area, Grayhorse Lodge is located in a remote section of the the Osage Indian Nation, in north-central Oklahoma near the Kansas border. It's almost smack dab between Tulsa, OK and Witchita, Kansas, more than an hour away from either city. There's not a lot of economic prosperity or opportunity in this region. When Scorcese's film crew came to the area to make his movie about an historic incident in the Osage Nation, they used the lodge for a not especially flattering scene that upset lots of Brother Masons. The lodge room looks today much as it looked a hundred years ago when the incident took place, and Scorcese wanted to use as many authentic locations as he could.
The film crew cleaned up the lodge room, gave it a fresh coat of paint, and brought in several antique props for both historical accuracy and visual interest (the pot-bellied stove was a prop). The lodge got a facelift and a little national attention out of the deal, local folks were hired as extras, and Fairfax and a couple of surrounding communities got a brief economic bump from the crew's hotel, dining and retail supply needs. But film crews move fast, like advancing armies, and they leave just as quickly as they came. The paint and attention wasn't enough to save Grayhorse Lodge. And as my friend pointed out, it doesn't help that the majority of Osage Indians are Roman Catholic and are unlikely to violate the prohibition of the Church against Freemasonry.
A Google street-view cruise through downtown Fairfax tells the story quickest. The majority of storefronts along North Main Street are closed and boarded up. There's a banner pleading "Save the Tall Chief Theater" in front of the local movie house that no longer shows films, but advertises a "Killers of the Flower Moon" memorial on its marquee. You can count the number of parked cars on one hand as you roll down the street. The lodge building was built in 1909 as the First National Bank, and the lodge room was added in 1924. The National Register of Historic Places calls it the "best example of Georgian Revival architecture in Osage County," and it's obvious that the Masons were proud of their home town enough to invest in the most impressive building in the county.
By holding on until this year, Grayhorse Lodge managed to last a full century.
Lodges close every day. No lodge is ever destined to last forever, and Masonry changes and adapts to suit the age, community, and society in which it resides.
I'm told that in Oklahoma, if the Grand Master seizes a charter, that lodge cannot ever be revived, but if the members vote to voluntarily surrender their charter, it CAN be revived in the future. The members of Grayhorse Lodge 124 surrendered theirs.
"For there is hope of a tree, if it be cut down, that it will sprout again, and that the tender branch thereof will not cease..."
